I said the same thing. The whole, making a list and sharing it with his church, is pretty creepy though. Definitely over the top.
I know there are several cops/deputies that go to my church. While I've yet to hear about any of them adding speeders to a prayer list, it is quite common for folks to ask the church to pray for members' relatives involved in drug and alcohol problems (most recently), along with those stricken with illness. It's not that uncommon to add folks to the prayer list that don't even attend our church or (maybe) any other church. While it may seem a little odd, I imagine especially to non-believers, it's really not so much.