While no system is perfect or fool proof, I'll take this one over your system of doing nothing.Unfortunately, the TSA manages to take away what I want while only giving the illusion of giving you what you want.
While no system is perfect or fool proof, I'll take this one over your system of doing nothing.
As I said, were it up to me to ensure the safety of my family and friends, I'd prefer to see armed military handling the job.
And as Jeremy stated, "You want to feel safe in an airport/airplane go to Germany or Israel". It's coming....society ensures it.
It happens I would rather people be interupted older or not. It sure isn't a nice way to do things.
Life goes on, one more safe airplane I can fly on. SO I can make money to pay for your SS later on.
+1And I have NEVER heard of an El Al flyer of any extended age being pulled from her wheelchair and frisked by the armed guards of El Al. NEVER. Do they search pregnant women at palestinian checkpoints? Sure, because those kids of attacks have happened. When my sister in law went to Israel the security was not like ours. I would never expect Zeidy or Bubby to be yanked from a wheelchair to get on a plane. Never.
El Al has basic sense and real security. We have the opposite.
And I have NEVER heard of an El Al flyer of any extended age being pulled from her wheelchair and frisked by the armed guards of El Al. NEVER. Do they search pregnant women at Palestinian checkpoints? Sure, because those kids of attacks have happened. When my sister in law went to Israel the security was not like ours. I would never expect Zeidy or Bubby to be yanked from a wheelchair to get on a plane. Never.
El Al has basic sense and real security. We have the opposite.
While no system is perfect or fool proof, I'll take this one over your system of doing nothing.
My major difference is that I'd rather see the armed militia handling the job.As I said, were it up to me to ensure the safety of my family and friends, I'd prefer to see armed military handling the job.
There is a reason that Posse Commitatus is law and why people are concerned about violations of it. Converting the US Military in any significant way from a Field Force to an extension of the police is to convert it to one trained as a "Regime Protection Force." Oh, it wouldn't be called that, and it may not start out functioning as one, but at Madeline Albright said "what's the good of having this large military if we don't use it?""There are, essentially, three types of forces in the world," Mike said, picking his words carefully. "Field forces, regime protection forces and show forces. Show forces are very good at parading. They are trained to look good, pretty much period. Some excellent combat units are also good at showing off, don't get me wrong. The Rhodesian Selous Scouts were bloody peacocks and marched better than the Coldstream Guards. But show forces are only there for show.
"Next, there are regime protection forces," Mike said, trying not to look at the Chief of Staff of the Georgian army. "Regime protection forces are, essentially, very large police forces. They are trained to suppress resistance to the regime, to break up riots, to ferret out guerillas and so forth. They're, really, peacekeeping forces in countries where peace is shaky. Due to the nature of their training, they're very good at coups. They're used to moving to specific places in cities and, for example, taking over broadcast stations or buildings that are important to a coup.
"Last, there are field armies. Field armies are designed to meet other forces on the field of battle and defeat them. That can be small unit or large unit, but that is their training. They may march well and they may be able to occasionally be used to keep the peace, but they're not fundamentally trained for either. Field armies are designed to destroy other forces and when used in a coup tend to break much more than they should. They also make various mistakes, like firing into crowds indiscriminately, that make the succeeding regime, even if the coup is successful, very unpopular. The vast majority of the American army is field forces. The only units that are not are Civil Affairs and MPs."
I'm sure that if we crush liberty enough we can feel quite safe, well, so long as you're not one the government decides to oppress today. Who knows, it might even lead to being safe, although evidence to date of these restrictions having that effect is mighty slim.And as Jeremy stated, "You want to feel safe in an airport/airplane go to Germany or Israel". It's coming....society ensures it.
You want to make things safer? Fine. I'm all for that. But find a way to do it that does not destroy the liberties that are at the heart of the United States of America.
guess in my 20k miles in the past 2 months, and a fully stamped Passports I've never seen TSA dick things up. Nor other airports not using TSA. I have seen people refused to enter due to guns.knifes and even a walking stick sword.lol
You must have won the lottery that day. lol
You people need to get out more instead of living in the basement sceeming up government plots against you. Seriously go feel the sun outside, take a trip. Hell even go for a walk.
Folks....do we not recall that on the morning of September 11, 2001, 2,794 innocent people died when 19 terrorists hijacked 4 aircraft and used them as killing machines? While I understand that seeing an elderly woman searched before boarding an aircraft is not pleasant....do you really not see the necessity in it?
Let me assure you that wheelchairs have many places to hide weapons....from ice picks to handguns....and I'm sure explosives. And if I'm hell bent on bringing down an aircraft or commandeering one to fly into another building to make a political statement....what better mule for weapons to be later commanded by a terrorist group than the elderly. "Hey mom, how would you like to fly to Vegas with me?" I firmly believe the next group of terrorists to strike U.S. soil won't necessarily have dark hair and eyes or come from the Middle East. Let me assure you that I've seen more than one frail looking person sitting in a wheel chair get up and run like a jack rabbit....and have personally pulled a concealed firearm from a wheelchair. I'm not saying she could have, or would have....but metal detectors do nothing when used to search a metal object. At that point it's hands on to be sure.
While I do sincerely sympathize....I urge you to see the necessity in it. Imagine your displeasure and grief if your wife or child were on a flight blown up by a terrorist that was not thoroughly checked by those charged with the task.
I do agree however, that a private security company should not be left with the task of seeing the skies are safe. If it were up to me that task would have been left to the U.S. military. Any member of such a team that doesn't do his or her job thoroughly or professionally should be fired on the spot. If your only complaint is the manner in which the lady was "handled", I urge you to contact TSA and complain. If your complaint is that how could they search such a frail, older lady....I really don't think the complaint is valid.
I am upset because it has come to this in the US
But Public Servant is right , A bad man could very easily hide a weapon, explosives , drugs You name it in a wheel chair making the elderly lady a mule if You will
I cant fault TSA workers for doing there jobs
I want Myself and Loved ones to be safe when on a flight
If it happens that someone has used a wheelchair to smuggle explosives thru a checkpoint onto a plane and that plane is destroyed then everyone will be complaining the TSA didnt do there job
just because you heard about it means its happened?
I bet you watch Fox news also.
Folks....do we not recall that on the morning of September 11, 2001, 2,794 innocent people died when 19 terrorists hijacked 4 aircraft and used them as killing machines? While I understand that seeing an elderly woman searched before boarding an aircraft is not pleasant....do you really not see the necessity in it?
snip.
Joe Williams- First of all, thank you for your service, I appreciate your sacrifice. I do however think you are comparing apples and oranges when comparing the guarding of nuclear weapons and Air Force Presidential Aircraft to airport terminal security. The former has no public access, while the latter has unrestricted public access. I haven't traveled via commercial air since 9/11 but would think that it would be a royal pain in the neck or maybe 3 feet lower. One problem with security, either border security (an impossibility) or airport security (another insurmountable task) is that these programs are directed by bureaucrats who just want to build their little empires and retire at the highest grade possible. The grunts who do the work are just doing their jobs as has been proscribed by a lot of folks in much higher pay grades. Are the TSA folks doing a job that could be done better? Sure. Is there a better way to do it? No doubt. Have there been any other sucessful hijackings since TSA took over? No. They must not be doing everything wrong.
As to the OP, I'm sure that the TSA grunts might have been able to handle the task a little more delicately than described, but I'm certain that they didn't decide that it would be a lot of fun to hassle an old lady in a wheelchair. Every time I do anything, if I Monday morning quarterback myself, I can find room for improvement. Those of you who can tell what a criminal, terrorist or accomplice looks like belong in the highest levels of CIA or FBI. It could save us a whole lot of money, time and trouble having you protect the country.
It does get a little tiresome to have some of you nitpick everyone's else's jobs, from the person who takes your order at Mickey D's, to the cop on the beat. Nobody is perfect. Give it a rest. Now when you get pepper sprayed at Walmart by the checkout person because you got mad that she asked you what you were going to shoot that .22 ammo in, then by all means, I want to hear you whine. I can always use a good laugh.
I don't think many of us are asking for to much from the TSA. We damn sure do not expect perfection from a government alphabet agency. What we do expect and probably should demand should be competence, compassion, and common sense!
YMMV!