Best Burger in Indiana?

[theweakerbrother]

Cheeseburger Po-Boy at Papa Roux

That being said, they haven't made them in a while...

Harass Papa!!!

@Hornadylnl: I didn't know that about the train robbers but it makes sense. I'll ask my grandma and see if she knows anything the next time I see her. Makes me hungry!!!

 

[Naptown]

I have some favorites. This is a random selection, but I just love burgers. No particular order....

Five Guys
Bone Fish Kobe Burger
Cheeseburger in Paradis
Bub's
Scotty's

 

[esrice]

Evan, next time you are up this way and are hungry, I'll buy you a burger!

You KNOW I'll take you up on that!

 

[Naptown]

you wouldn't think of here but the trojan horse in b-town has a fantastic burger as well.

Don't forget about those Black and Tans!

 

[steepo17]

The "57 Chevy" at Shelby Street Diner, Indianapolis OR the Working Man's Friend has a pretty good burger too.

 

[PapaScout]

The Brick in Jonesville.

 

[esrice]

The Brick in Jonesville.

Ok so this one has come up several times now.

Talking with some friends last night about his topic and they too suggested The Brick.

Might have to do some investigatin' . . . .

 

[hornadylnl]

Ok so this one has come up several times now.

Talking with some friends last night about his topic and they too suggested The Brick.

Might have to do some investigatin' . . . .

Don't forget, coat and tie required!

 

[esrice]

Don't forget, coat and tie required!

I'm gonna rent a tux just to be on the safe side.

 

[IndySSD]

I'm gonna rent a tux just to be on the safe side.

Let me know when you do this, we can carpool and I'll photograph the occasion.....

 

[Lex Concord]

Boogie Burger in Broad Ripple is good. Gotta get the garlic fries with the Disco Inferno.

For sheer mass (still with really good flavor) the Double Big Daddy Burger at Big Daddy's is the way to go.

Still looking forward to trying 5-Guys...

 

[theweakerbrother]

I'm gonna rent a tux just to be on the safe side.

Evan's is free.. the rest of you, bring cash.

 

[IndySSD]

Evan's is free.. the rest of you, bring cash.

Always have cash if I'm going somewhere that's got food for sale!!

 

[littletommy]

I know we are not talking fast food here, but man, I could probably throw down half a dozen of those mushroom and swiss burgers from Rallys. (well, thats if my wife isn't around to stop me).

 

[djl02]

Its hard to beat a homemade burger grilled with Lipton onion soup mix,dressed w/bacon. I havent eaten anything as good.
Best burger around here takeout would have to be Culver's dressed bacon burger.Just has that old fashion taste.

 

[hornadylnl]

I'm to the point that I'd much rather have a good burger than a steak. With a good burger, you get so many different flavors blending together.

 

[Kirk Freeman]

Hinkle's Hamburgers, Bloomington, Indiana.

 

[hornadylnl]

Hinkle's Hamburgers, Bloomington, Indiana.

Is that the same Hinkles as Madison?

This isn't a burger but it sure was great. I just got done eating it.

My daughter got shrimp. She said she ate 12 and there were 12 left.

This is the apple dumpling my wife ordered. She also got a pork BBQ sandwich.

All of this came to $29 with 3 drinks. The lady working was extremely nice.

 

[esrice]

Ok, so I took my wife out this evening, and we ended up at Shallos in Greenwood.

Appetizer was a PILE of onion rings!

It's not on the menu, but I requested that they beer batter and deep fry my burger. Then they topped it with cheese, bacon, sweet onion, lettuce, and tomato. I added a few beer battered onion rings from our appetizer just for good measure. Dipping the final bites into a side of ranch dressing helped to completely solidify my veins.

Wife ordered the tenderloin. It was ok, but nothing to write home about.

Then, since I hadn't yet had complete heart failure, we hit the nearby Cold Stone Creamery.

Yum!

 

[nighthawk80]

MMMMM, I like Shallos!