Hello John, You have the story a little wrong and I will admit that wasn't a high point. For the thousands reading this thread the muzzleloaders were in fact sitting below our tree stand 50 yards away. The buck was one I had just shot and was lying in a multiflora rose bramble. I sent my teenage son back to get a muzzleoader to finish off but suddenly the deer had one last burst of adrenilin as I grabbed it by the antlers. What appeared to be a deer breathing it's last was now a stomping, kicking tornado spraying me with blood. Since it was the first buck I had in 19 years I didn't want the lose him so I foolishly held on the the antlers. My son came back with the muzzleloader and for a split second the deer stood there unmoving. In another foolish move I told my son the put the barrel to the deer ribs and shoot him. ( The angle was such the shot would have been away from me.) But, before he could, the deer lunged and jumped away. We tracked it into our neighbor's cornfield where it was once again lying down breathing its last. This time we didn't take any chances...I fired the muzzleloader my son was carrying only to have the main charge not go off. The second shot worked. All that for a small six-point that weighed less than I did. Like I said, not one of my finer moments. Some foolish moves? Yes. Un-ethical? We were not poaching. I didn't waste any meat. The deer was tagged. So, you tell me.
Now, if you want to talk ethical smack, what about people taking a crap in someone elses ground deer stand while they're working on Saturdays...hmmm.
The first story...
While not really unethical, it surely is asinine to grab a deer like that...
But very fuuny for us though, thanks...
The second story...
Depends I guess on how good of a friend they are...