Albertson's Sport Shop on US 30 just east of Warsaw has been there forever -- inventory is somewhat lacking but they are friendly and knowledgeable. T&Z Armory in South Bend is my personal favorite at the moment; they do friendly & fair FFL transfers, custom coatings, good inventory.
Does anyone know if Crystal Brooke (I think that's the name or something close to it) in North Webster still in business? I havent been over that way in about 5 yrs.
Ditto Nathan's post about Bass and Bucks. Their phone number is: 260-569-1853. If you're not familiar with the Wabash area, your GPS should take you right to it using the address Nathan provided.