LCP vs P3at

[Glock Lover]

I ended up getting a Taurus TCP Like it so far.

 

[Sasquatchhunter]

they never had to recall the keltec...just sayin

 

[Markedup]

I voted for the P3AT
because I own one.

Thanks

Mark

 

[Phil502]

they never had to recall the keltec...just sayin

I have the Ruger, I never saw the Keltec so I can't compare.

That recall seems funny to me, the Ruger actually has a hammer, it is just "concealed" I am not sure how dropping it is going to bring the hammer all the way back then release it to discharge, unless the hammer does not need to go all the way back to cause a discharge? Long trigger pull too on it.

 

[PLANEMECH]

Have never owned a P3 yet but have had it's older little brother the P32 for about 6 years never had a jam or problem yet. Rarely ever leave the house with out it. Yeah it may look a little rough on the finish but give me functionablity(if that is a word) anyday. Got a friend that I kind of talked into buying a P3 and now he swears buy it also.

 

[Cemetery-man]

The LCP was featured on "American Guardian" last night on the Outdoor channel. Lots of range footage and talk about the popularity of the new pocket pistols and .380.

 

[tradertator]

I've had both, sold the keltec and kept the ruger. Maybe it's just me, but the trigger in the ruger feels a little smoother. I had several ftf's with keltec, which is unacceptable if your planning on carrying it for defense. I put the keltec belt clip on the ruger, and it fits like a charm. I also installed an armalaser, which has worked out very well. Call me crazy, but I like the absence of a bulky switch on a firearm that I can only wrap 3 fingers around.

 

[dyerwatcher]

Imitation is the sincerest form of flattery...........

 

[Brandan]

I love my P3at. Shoots well, and they are super affordable.

Brandan

 

[sharpetop]

I own both, [2nd gen P3AT]. No question, the Ruger fit and finish is superior. I'm also not fond of the extractor set up on the Kel-Tec. It looks like an after thought. It also has been know to come loose when firing.

As for reliability, the nod also goes to the LCP. It's been 100%, where as the P3AT has occasional FTE issues.

As for price, they were both less than $300.

 

[Larryjr]

I have shot both but don't own either. I think Kel-Tec is slightly better for this type of gun though the lcp looks nicer. I am anxious to give the new Taurus tcp a crack!

 

[danmdevries]

I've had both.

My biggest gripe with the KelTec other than the rough finish on the frame, was that there was no slidelock. Not a huge deal but personally I prefer having a slide lock.

If I were to buy a second pocket gun I think I'd pick up another P3AT because of the price difference.

 

[right2arms]

I think this issue is being overcomplicated. The two guns are meant to be carry-anywhere, backup sort of guns.

If you cant finish it with 6 (or 6+1) rounds of 380 +P then you need to retreat, or consider a different CCW.

fit, finish, features, are not meant to be important. These are inexpensive, backup, carry when you cant carry anything else- guns.

Now, if you have found it to be unreliable, then that is a different story. I haven't had an issue with mine. Just be aware that a light, tiny gun with a (relatively) powerful round will experience more muzzle flip than a larger gun you can get your whole hand around.

 

[Glocker]

I bought a brand new P3AT keltec(new generation extractor) a year ago. It jammed on hollow points right out of the box every round. But I was able to shoot FMJ ammo reliably on the 2 magazines I loaded...the gun now sits in my Safe. I carried it a total of about 5 times last summer because I had no choice and needed the concealment.

Thats my experince with it but I don't know much about the Ruger LCP. I'm still looking for a nice pocket pistol that I can feel comfortable with.

 

[XDs4me]

As stated in a earlier post I have the LCP with CT laser and love it,but I just bought a Diamondback 380 that I waiting for. When it comes in I get to the range I will give a report as to compare it to my LCP. For those that havent heard of the Diamond back it looks like a Baby Glock.

 

[Dogman]

The wife carries a P3AT so I'll go with that one.