Sig P220 Compact would be my choice.
In fact I think I just may get me one!
Do you like your Beretta sub compact?I'm here in Ft Wayne and have a few you can handle or shoot if you want. I have:
HK45C - .45ACP
Springfield Micro Compact - .45ACP
Beretta PX4 Sub Compact in .40 S&W
My EDC is the HK45C and I carry IWB at 4:00
Do you like your Beretta sub compact?
I totally understand what you mean about the ugly/pretty part. I bought one in 9mm and was suprised about how much I like it. People are always curious when they see it.It's butt-ugly, but it is a great piece. Flawless in feed and function. It carries well and the recoil isn't bad at all. I like the weapon, but I'm not a big fan of the .40 S&W. The main reason I bought it was because it looks like a pit bull on steroids. It's so ugly that it's pretty.
Do you like your Springfield, otherwise?
I have a XD40SC that can conceal pretty easily. The shorter grip makes the difference, along with a good holster.
I also know some folks that conceal a full-sized XD, so maybe a different holster would help you?
Not being a 1911 fan, I carry a Kahr CW45 or a Glock 36. They are much lighter than a 1911 and carry better.