Breaded tenderloins

[forgop]

I didn't see a thread dedicated to the best sandwich available in the state (and least likely to find anywhere other than Iowa).

My top recommendations in Indianapolis:

1). Southport Bar and Grill
2). Billy O'neals
3). Bourbon Street Distillery

Those are top 3 and clearly above the rest I've had. Others very close to one another and still leave you quite happy are:

Sahm's(Fishers)
Tie Dye Grill (Tuesdays only-Irvington)
Plumps Last Shot(Broad Ripple)
Oaken Barrel(greenwood)
B&C's Hideout(New Palestine)
Dawson's on Main (speedway)
Bugsy's(southeast-get the breaded mushrooms-not the avg breaded mushroom FYI)

Still a lot of places I haven't tried, but these will not disappoint.

 

[MrsGungho]

give Edwards Drive In a try on Raymond & Sherman

you won't be disappointed

 

[forgop]

give Edwards Drive In a try on Raymond & Sherman

you won't be disappointed

Edwards is ok-all the above are better in my opinion. The idea they were featured on Man vs Food to feature the breaded tenderloin is kind of a joke.

 

[hornadylnl]

The best I've had is this honky tonk joint in Norman. Last time I was there, it was closed but I heard it reopened.

Nick's in Huntington.

Mr Dave's in North Manchester.

 

[perry]

The Aristocrat at 52nd & College. It's recently reopened after a fire pretty much gutted the place. I need to get back down there.

http://www.facebook.com/photo.php?fbid=10151299009634292&set=a.10151266242269292.487864.128125019291

 

[public servant]

give Edwards Drive In a try on Raymond & Sherman

you won't be disappointed

While they're still good...they ain't what they were 25 years ago...but what is I guess.

 

[CountryBoy19]

I'm sure a lot of the places have a delicious breaded tenderloin, I've never tried one. But a small-town place down by me makes a pretty darn good one. It's call Holt's Cafe. They are nearly out of business and down to just a few days a week that they're open with odd hours but it's still a good tenderloin. You can walk in and see all the tenderloins soaking in buttermilk just over the counter and they bread them fresh. The bun leaves a bit to be desired as it's only a standard, king-size sandwich roll but the tenderloin is top-notch.

 

[rockhopper46038]

I rate the tenderloin at the Lockerbie Pub as the best I've had in Indy. And I've had a few. It is an epiphany.

 

[Rookie]

I've never had a good tenderloin. They're always dry.

 

[fullauto 45]

New Bethel Ordinary in beautiful downtown Wanamaker has a great breaded tenderloin.

 

[PaulF]

Green Street Station in Brownsburg makes a Beer-Battered tenderloin sandwich for which I will, quite literally, go out of my way to eat.

-Paul

 

[digitalrebel80]

whits inn in Whiteland yum

 

[indyk]

loins loins loins

I have to agree one OF the best tederloins are made at Bourbon Street down town, thats all ive ordered there for 5 years lol.

 

[kbailey]

Top Notch Bar & Grill in Brookston ... it's an epic tenderloin

 

[kobra]

Main View in North Manchester is awesome. It's not a huge tenderloin and paper thin. It does overhang a 8" sub bun. But, it's thick and meaty.

Pitt's bar in Portland makes a good one too.

I want to try Mr. Dave's but I've never been in town when they're open.

 

[phylodog]

I can't think of a breaded tenderloin sandwich that I didn't like. Salt, mustard and onions and I'm making the "nummy-nummy" sounds. Guess I'm easy to please.

 

[Buck69]

Thr Rockola cafe on east brookville road does a nice job as well

 

[Hoosier Cowboy]

Thanks to this thread I'm now hungry and feel the need to do ALOT of traveling today

 

[FatsMcKay]

Pawn Shop Pub has got maybe the best one.

 

[cbko4]

Mug-n-bun (westside of indy)

Frostbite in Avon

There is also a smaller pub off of 86th street (think its actually called 86th street pub) that has a tenderloin that you can supreme in which they add all the toppings and on top of that put ham and cheese and melt it....very good