Great thread, information. Not to hijack, but I think what I am asking may help the OP with his decision also.
For us newbies that are considering reloading, could you throw together a checklist of good equipment, without robbing the bank, that includes everything needed to start reloading? Good enough that we may never need to upgrade to get good quality, consistent results. Like you, I hate to get a bunch of items that either I don't need or will need replacing in the near future with a better item. I have been considering 9mm and 5.56. Thanks.
The problem is that peoples' opinions will differ. So it could be debated forever. But I'll give you some generalities, based on MY OPINION. Others will differ, and that's fine, I'm not going to debate it.
-Press - I don't like the cheaper Lee presses. A RCBS Rockchucker is the best deal in a single stage. IMHO everyone should start out on a single stage press. If you shoot a lot of pistol this will suck after awhile, so you will want to upgrade to a progressive. But I suggest you learn on a single stage. I reloaded even pistol on one for years, I just did it in the winter when I had time for the slower process.
-Dies - Lee carbide dies for pistol. RCBS best economy for rifle.
- Caliper - RCBS digital is fine
- Scale - I went from a crappy $30 digital to a RCBS Chargemaster. The Chargemaster is awesome, but pricey. But I'd look at equivalent scales to the scale component. Sorry, no experience to give you specifics.
- Lee dippers are great if reloading pistol on a single stage. Alternatively, a simple powder thrower. Tricklers are not for the sane person.
- Have to have a Hornady case gauge if you need to bump back rifle case shoulders
- I have a cheap Lyman crank trimmer. Works fine. Important to have one with good adjustment locks.
- A Lee or RCBS hand primer. I have the Lee with a shell holder kit.
- A Hornady ogive case measuring tool (clips to caliper) is pretty necessary to get rifle rounds set right.
- A hand chamfering tool for rifle cases that have been trimmed
- Powder funnel
- Reloading blocks, or get a block of wood and a spade bit and make your own
I think that about sums up the basics? I started with this and other than the crappy scale, have not felt the need to upgrade anything (other than getting a Hornady LnL progressive). My original load-out didn't cost much more than a kit.