Who makes the best pizza?

[Expat]

I would agree with Kirk on Mother Bear's, but I admit that it is all mixed in with a fond remembrance of college and all that.

Bruno's is a good pizza. Masimo's is also good but fairly local I believe. I like Domino's better than Papa John's. By the way, ham and pineapple do NOT belong on a pizza.

We make our own pretty often.

 

[ATOMonkey]

My favorite pizzas

Pizza Den Coatsville IN - Blue Cheese and Buffalo Chicken

Mediterranean Pizza Brownsburg IN - Alfredo Chicken pizza

Mother Bears Bloomington - Whatever the name of the all meat pizza is. Delicious.

And I'm afraid to admit it, but for some sadistic reason I really like Pizza Hut. No idea why.

 

[Cemetery-man]

Wooden Peel in Bremen, IN.

 

[Fletch]

BJ's Brewhouse. You have one in Greenwood. The BJ's Favorite rules on high.

 

[scottka]

Thanks for the heads up on Buck Creek Pizza! A few of my buddies and I went up there for supper tonight. It was definitely worth the drive. Great bunch of people workin' there. Nice as could be.

 

[sloaba01]

800 degrees in Fort Wayne has great great brick oven pizza's!! Great toppings too

 

[steve666]

Bazbeaux

 

[SirRealism]

Enzos makes a pretty good NY-style pie.

 

[trnsplntfrmohio]

In the Fort, Ollie's/Oleys (hetfysi)

 

[AZ Hunter]

Pizza Shack in Tipton is pretty good! We used to drive up there a lot as a kid to eat there. The had a nacho pizza that was so tasty! mmmmmm pizzzzzzaaaaa

We live in Tucson now so the recommendations won't matter....we order Papa Murphy's a lot though. They got a $10 large 5 meat stuffed pizza....one slice and you are done!

 

[D-Bo]

Pizza King is the best.

 

[Indy317]

Pizza Shack in Tipton is pretty good! We used to drive up there a lot as a kid to eat there.

I wouldn't mind trying the Pizza Shack in Tipton. The thing is, I would like to take my nieces on the Pizza Train that leaves Noblesville and stops in Tipton. The thing is, the prices for the food are outrageous. If you eat at the Pizza Shack, they want almost $10 per adult, and either $5 or $3 per kid (depending on age). For me to take my nieces, it would cost me $26 for pizza and drinks. This doesn't include the train tickets. For this total excursion, it would cost me $58.00. That is just way too pricey for me. I think I might drive up to Tipton to check this place out instead of taking the train.

 

[right winger]

Pappa Johns

 

[rockhopper46038]

Pappa Johns

Your Pizza Tasters Of Middle America -INdiana Edition (or PTOMAINE, for short) card has just been REVOKED!

 

[Andre46996]

Pizza King is the best.

This almost deserves a neg rep...

 

[Knife Lady]

Greek's Pizzaria in Fishers. Ask for Mike or Raphael. They also buy a lot of guns and knives. Great guys.

 

[warangelcometh]

In NWI (Portage and surrounding areas) you can't beat JJ's Pizza shack. The "stuffed" pizza is absolutely heaven and goes great cold breakfast pizza the next morning. Check it out at jjspizzashack.com

 

[revsaxon]

Gioranos. Best deep dish pizza known to man. Only part about living in Illinois I truly miss.

 

[Kelevra TAR-21]

In Fort Wayne Pizza Forum and Marcos. It used to be Oley's until they started using fake cheese.

 

[Kelevra TAR-21]

Greek's Pizzaria in Fishers. Ask for Mike or Raphael. They also buy a lot of guns and knives. Great guys.

They own my favorite pizza place in Fort Wayne. Pizza Forum.