Weathertech vs. Huskyliner Floor Liners

[Boiled Owl]

The Mrs was big on Weathertech, so we put a set in the 2003 GMC crew.
Cons:
Lots of slush melting and sloshing around your feet. Lay the gloves down by my feet, they are wet now as there are no ribs to contain the melt water.
Dust lays on mat...open door in the wind...dust goes airborne...again no ribs to contain the dust.
Nothing to hold the weathertech in place on passenger side or the rear floor.... feet push them up under the dash.
Plastic curls away from edges. The back mat gets caught when the seat is slid back.
Pros:
Nice trough to drain the water out the door

Added a new truck to the fleet last year and bought the Husky exact liners. Flexible. Ribbed to contain dirt and water. Nibbs on bottom keep them in place. No curling, seat slides mat stays.
+1 Husky here.

 

[Principal Skinr]

The Mrs was big on Weathertech, so we put a set in the 2003 GMC crew.
Cons:
Lots of slush melting and sloshing around your feet. Lay the gloves down by my feet, they are wet now as there are no ribs to contain the melt water.
Dust lays on mat...open door in the wind...dust goes airborne...again no ribs to contain the dust.
Nothing to hold the weathertech in place on passenger side or the rear floor.... feet push them up under the dash.
Plastic curls away from edges. The back mat gets caught when the seat is slid back.
Pros:
Nice trough to drain the water out the door

Added a new truck to the fleet last year and bought the Husky exact liners. Flexible. Ribbed to contain dirt and water. Nibbs on bottom keep them in place. No curling, seat slides mat stays.
+1 Husky here.

Husky says their exact liners aren't made for my truck, which is shocking, because they only made something like 800,000 of them a year. That's the mat I'd really like to have.

I don't like hearing about the edges rolling up. I may look at the regular mats. The Husky classics don't have any ridges, either.
I'd hate to pay the premium for those Weathertechs and have the plastic curl away.

 

[Boiled Owl]

What year is your "older" super crew Ford?

 

[Spear Dane]

Never heard of the huskyliners but I have Weathertech in both my cars and have been perfectly happy with them.

 

[Razer]

+1 Husky. I have had Weathertech fitment problems a couple times on two separate vehicles. Thin, overall not impressive. Husky seems to be a much better made product that does not move around like my WT does. I will not purchase WT again short a major redesign or new model of the mats, until then the Husky is a clear winner for me anyway.

 

[igotdiesel2]

I have had Huskyliners in my Dodges. When I bought my Ford. The owner said he put the mats that are in it the day he bought the truck. They are Fox Weatherboot. They are in the front and back floorboards of my crew cab. The thing I like about these is that they are hard plastic with carpet. And if you pull them out, the factory carpet looks brand new. Did I mention that my truck is 17 years old? -Jason

Truck Floor Mats | Weatherboots

 

[Principal Skinr]

What year is your "older" super crew Ford?

2002.

 

[gtpilot21]

I have weathertech and they are great. I have four kids and they get a lot of traffic. Every few months I take them out and spray them off and they look great.
Best Birthday gift that year.