Springfield EMP .40 vs Kimber ultra carry II

[sig1473]

I own a Kimber Tactical Pro II and an EMP 9. Fit and finish hands down go to the EMP. Function once again goes to the EMP. It is a nice little tack driver. For both guns being +1k, my vote definitely goes to the EMP. Not really impressed at all with Kimber.

 

[lrs019]

I haven't shot an EMP, but own a Kimber custom target in .45 and I love it. My husband has a Kimber 1911 also...which is his everyday carry gun and also uses it for IDPA, I just use mine for fun (plinking, and I shoot PPC). Hubby has put more rounds through his than I have, but neither of us have had any problems with them. I've had mine for about 11-12 yrs., and my hubby has had his longer. They're reliable, easy to field strip and clean, and perform very well. Mine has 2 safeties...one is on the backstrap and the other is a switch, like a run-of-the-mill safety. As a woman, it's kinda hard for me to conceal a 1911, but I would have no problems carrying it cocked and ready to go because of the safety system on it. The trigger does have a lighter pull, which I've heard some people say they don't like, but I like it that way. Good luck with your choice.

 

[Indy574]

I have only handled these two guns so for what it is worth. I really think the SA EMP has it's stuff together, I think it has a better feel in "my" hand. I just really wish they would offer it in a .45.

 

[Johnny C]

I have a 9mm EMP and it has FTF and stovepipe issues with all 3 magazines.
I bought it used, and I don't know if it is an early model or not.
I need to send it back to springfield one of these days...sigh

Johnny C

 

[mk18cqb]

I love my EMP, i have the 40, my father in law has the 9mm. GREAT gear

 

[Amishman44]

EMP!

 

[sig1473]

I have a 9mm EMP and it has FTF and stovepipe issues with all 3 magazines.
I bought it used, and I don't know if it is an early model or not.
I need to send it back to springfield one of these days...sigh

Johnny C

I had to send a gun back to Springfield! Great customer service and they will pay for everything. My EMP has had NO issues yet, but I have a newer one.

 

[Wild Deuce]

I have a 9mm EMP and it has FTF and stovepipe issues with all 3 magazines.
I bought it used, and I don't know if it is an early model or not.
I need to send it back to springfield one of these days...sigh

Johnny C

I had to send a gun back to Springfield! Great customer service and they will pay for everything. My EMP has had any issues yet, but I have a newer one.

Johny C, do NOT delay any longer. Call Springfield Armory first thing in the morning. They will either snail mail you a return label or email you instructions with a Return Authorization number and how to get your gun picked up for repair. They will want the gun, all three magazines, description (manufacturer/type/weight) of the ammo and a detailed note of the problem.

I had to do a return with SA before (not the EMP). From the time I picked up the phone (first contact) until I had the repaired gun back in my hands was about 98 hours.
**Oh yeah. Forgot to mention ... it was all on their dime.

 

[sig1473]

Johny C, do NOT delay any longer. Call Springfield Armory first thing in the morning. They will either snail mail you a return label or email you instructions with a Return Authorization number and how to get your gun picked up for repair. They will want the gun, all three magazines, description (manufacturer/type/weight) of the ammo and a detailed note of the problem.

I had to do a return with SA before (not the EMP). From the time I picked up the phone (first contact) until I had the repaired gun back in my hands was about 98 hours.

Yeah, it doesn't matter if you are the original owner or 20th. By far the best customer service I have dealt with over the years concerning guns.

 

[Knuckle Head]

I have friends with Kimbers and I have yet to hear any complaints about them. Either choice sounds like a fine one, I own the EMP. I have the 9 not the 40, but it doesn't matter, they both have purty mouths..................decisions, decisions,.

 

[triplerider]

Amazing! In about two weeks time my EMP is back from Springfield with a new and pinned ejector. Looks like a heavy duty version of the original, so it oughtta work fine.
Colt, are you paying attention to the turnaround time? ahh, I woke you? Sorry...

 

[flyboy727]

I just ordered a EMP 9 yesterday, cant wait to get it.

I have a SA loaded ultra compact 45, love it, all stainless, shoots great!

 

[LLDJR]

Wow, I am going thru this same dilemma, except I am considering the Kimber Ultra Carry II , EMP 40 and the STI Escort. I'm thinking .40 caliber is OK too.

I have a Kimber, no issues and love the feel of the Ultra, and I love the feel of the EMP as well, but I cant find an Escort to look at anywhere local.

 

[FN USA]

EMP all the way! its a great gun!

 

[LLDJR]

Held a EMP .40 yesterday, it will be the next 1911 to round out my 1911 collection

 

[LLDJR]

Decision made,, held the EMP, held the Ultra Carry II, held the EMP, held the Ultra Carry II,, went back, repeated the process.


Bought an Stainless Ultra Carry II ,

To be continued...

 

[dboz]

You won't be disappointed. I never even had break in period with mine, just 100% reliable shooting from day one. And I like that the stainless finish does not show the carry wear. If it were not for the top of the sights showing finish wear, the gun that I have carried daily for 3 years could pass for a safe queen. I hope you enjoy yours.

 

[Cam]

Decision made,, held the EMP, held the Ultra Carry II, held the EMP, held the Ultra Carry II,, went back, repeated the process.


Bought an Stainless Ultra Carry II ,

To be continued...

Recently picked up an Ultra Carry as well. I couldn't be happier with it. Been completely problem free for close to 700 rounds so far.

 

[mike21]

EMP no question

 

[Cemetery-man]

You made the right decision. My Kimber Ultra carry II is the best handgun in my collection and the only choice for me to carry. Never a single issue, shoots great, feels great in hand, etc., etc..