S&W M&P Sucks

[Explosior]

I've got two M&P 40's, owned them for a couple of yrs. Shot hundreds of rounds through them. The only problem I've ever had is the white dot fell out of the front sight on one of them, which means nothing to me. I instinctive shoot.

 

[WallyJJ]

Enough said


Proof? There's 2 threads where a M&P 9 and a Shield blew up.

For what it's worth, I was one of those threads. It was my first shield so I had 100% failure rate. I have bought two more so now I only have a 33% failure rate. Things are looking up!

edit... forgot if we are talking M&P I also bought a FS 9 so I guess I am down to 25% failure rate!

 

[mdm2272]

I have no complaints about mine.....to each their own i guess

 

[whitetailbowhunter]

This is the worst thread i've read in awhile. i carry and shoot my m&p9c constantly and have yet to have a FTF or FTE. P.s. I hate glocks. Just sayin.

 

[RobbyMaQ]

I agree. they all suck. Bring all of your M&P's to me, and I will dispose of them properly.

 

[lovemachine]

LOL

The thread was meant to be a joke because of the Glock Sucks thread.

But if you guys REALLY want to talk about it, I had a M&P9c that jammed, was completely unreliable. I ditched it for a Glock 26 that hasn't failed yet, and has been ran hard.

There's a thread about it as well.

I don't doubt M&P's are good guns, but MY experience with them hasn't been good.

 

[code_red]

LOL

The thread was meant to be a joke because of the Glock Sucks thread.

But if you guys REALLY want to talk about it, I had a M&P9c that jammed, was completely unreliable. I ditched it for a Glock 26 that hasn't failed yet, and has been ran hard.

There's a thread about it as well.

I don't doubt M&P's are good guns, but MY experience with them hasn't been good.

Yeah, thanks for the m&pc. I replaced the ejector and it has been flawless ever since.

 

[Mr. Neal]

I must agree. I bought an M&P40 last year and it was terrible out of the box the trigger was junk, had to spend $85 on a apex kit the dot on the front sight fell off twice and I broke a slide stop assembly but it was kinda my fault on that one. Haha.

 

[BJones]

So far this week I have seen M&P sucks, Glock sucks, Taurus sucks. They all probably have thier issues but I know lots of folks who love them all.

 

[Markedup]

"S&W M&P Sucks"

You are inditing a whole lot of handguns.
I sometimes carry a 5" S&W M&P. It has
proved very reliable.You are ignoring more
than a century of production with your, I think,
unfounded, thread title.

Thanks

Mark

 

[Sgtusmc]

Love my M&P VTAC. No failures whatsoever.

 

[OkieGirl]

LOL

The thread was meant to be a joke because of the Glock Sucks thread.

But if you guys REALLY want to talk about it, I had a M&P9c that jammed, was completely unreliable. I ditched it for a Glock 26 that hasn't failed yet, and has been ran hard.

There's a thread about it as well.

I don't doubt M&P's are good guns, but MY experience with them hasn't been good.

I just saw this thread...and read all the way thru like a good little poster. LOL! For a minute there I thought you were serious and was gonna EDUCATE.

I have several M&P's of various calibers and yes one is a 9c, but that was before the tragic boating accident of course. I've had a few failures to feed but that was from my actions not the firearms (not cleaned properly prior to range time or poor choice of store bought ammo).

 

[Deet]

I must concur, I thought this thread was gonna convince me that the M&P sucked. It did not work.

 

[Fordtough25]

Wife and I put a couple mags through her M&P 9 yesterday, shot great! I have no problems with the M&P full size pistols, but I love my Glocks. My G34 is calling my name!

 

[churchmouse]

I have owned one glock that broke a piece out of the frame, and seen two others. I have also seen one bulge a barrel, one break a slide, and another shear off a barrel lug. Does that mean glocks suck? I have seen a S&W K frame bulge a barrel and a model 29 with the cylinder blown in pieces. I have seen an AR come apart on the firing line and embed slivers of aluminum in people. I have seen a 92fs break a locking block. I have seen a $12,000 Krieghoff shotgun split a barrel. Heck I even threw a connecting rod through the oil pan on a 396 Chevy. Mechanical things can and do break sometimes.

BTW, I do not own an M&P pistol, so it is not like I have a horse in the race.

Admit it...you were beating on the chevy pretty hard...Yes.....

Man made....it will break.

I have 1 M&P and it is an AR.
I have 1 S&W 1911PD


Both are great pieces.

 

[sig40]

my wife has a m&p 9c and has not ever had a problem with it.