The triggers really suck on a lot of those little options. Check out a Bersa Thunder 380 or 380cc. They are great guns and big enough to be easy on handling and recoil but small enough to easily conceal.
I'm a little curious about what your criteria is for determining "best" and "worst"? I have never had a Bersa .380 in my hands so I cannot speak from experience, but a quick look at the specs for the two guns raises some questions in my mind. The Bersa holds more rounds and I imagine it is cheaper, although my quick look did not turn up the MSRP. I assume the Bersa also has less felt recoil, but the little Smith wins every other category. By looking at the physical dimensions of the gun, the Thunder is much closer to the Shield than it is to the Bodyguard. I'm not trying to be controversial on this, I just wonder what your priorities are in making this determination.If you want a .380 your best bet is the Bersa Thunder .380. Your worst is the Smith & Wesson Bodyguard, but they sure are good looking.