Maybe I should have posted that in the joke of the day thread?
Mr. Lugar,
I am very disappointed in the news report that you have endorsed Sonya Sotomayor. She is completely unsuited to sitting on the United States Supreme Court, as based on her own words
While "compassion" and "understanding" and even "wisdom" may have their place on a jury or even in a judge during the sentencing phase, they have no place in an Appellate Court Judge, let alone a Supreme Court Justice. The duty of Judges in those roles is to see that the law is in accordance with the Constitution as written and, if it is, to see that the law is followed as written. Ms. Sotomayor's statements have made clear that she does not believe that and will instead decide based on what she believes the law should be, regardless of what the Constitution and the Law actually are. This is unacceptable in the Supreme Court.
Also, I was unaware that intelligence and wisdom came with a redoubled X chromosome or from having ancestors from particular parts of the globe. Ms. Sotomayor, the "wise latina woman," is obviously of a different opinion. And speaking of a self-proclaimed "wise latina woman," I have never met anybody who actually was wise who referred to him or herself as wise. One of the first precepts of wisdom is how little one actually knows in the scheme of things.
Sotomayor is completely unsuited to the role of Supreme Court Justice and voting to confirm her would be a complete miscarriage of your "advice and consent" duties as a United States Senator.
Members of the republican party are perfectly capable of being extremely partisan when it makes sense to do so. However, in this case, Sotomayor is a lock, and it would only hurt Republicans to aggressively attack her nomination. They aren't going to win any constituents over by attacking her (the Republican base isn't going anywhere), but they have the possibility of alienating even more of the hispanic vote. It's unfortunate, but identity politics is alive and well in both parties.
Members of the republican party are perfectly capable of being extremely partisan when it makes sense to do so. However, in this case, Sotomayor is a lock, and it would only hurt Republicans to aggressively attack her nomination. They aren't going to win any constituents over by attacking her (the Republican base isn't going anywhere), but they have the possibility of alienating even more of the hispanic vote. It's unfortunate, but identity politics is alive and well in both parties.