Logical extensions of bathroom decision

[hoosierdoc]

If A man chooses to live as a woman, now he is allowed in the women's bathroom because he has chosen to be a woman.

Is he then forced to sign up for the selective service?

Is he hit with indecent exposure if he exposes his chest? Should I do a mammogram on him every year?

If we are to believe children and their gender identity and treat them as they believe, what else does this extend to? If they believe they are 18, do we treat them as such? Can a five-year-old vote or get married simply because they believe they are older?

In New York City, can a transfat now enter any food it chooses?

 

[RobbyMaQ]

Are you identifying as a woman doc? Cuz that was a whole lot of questions going on there.

 

[hoosierdoc]

Are you identifying as a woman doc? Cuz that was a whole lot of questions going on there.

Just looking for more ammo in my discussions with others. I am not a woman, but I try to be as close to a particular one as possible.

 

[BiscuitNaBasket]

I can't INGO today.

 

[Lowe0]

If A man chooses to live as a woman

Before going any further, what evidence do you have that gender dysphoria is a choice?

 

[hoosierdoc]

Before going any further, what evidence do you have that gender dysphoria is a choice?

it's not relative to my discussion, so we'll ignore that part of it

 

[The Meach]

If A man chooses to live as a woman, now he is allowed in the women's bathroom because he has chosen to be a woman.

Correct. and women who have transitioned to men can use the men's room

like this fine gentlemen:

Is he then forced to sign up for the selective service?

A transwoman, yes. A transman, No. messed up right? luckily congress has put forth a bill to include women in SS. So hopefully that issue is soon to be resolved.

Is he hit with indecent exposure if he exposes his chest? Should I do a mammogram on him every year?

a. Yes i believe she would be but i guess that would be up to local or state laws.
b. No that is silly, Transwomen don't have mammary glands to scan. the breasts a purely cosmetic.

If we are to believe children and their gender identity and treat them as they believe, what else does this extend to? If they believe they are 18, do we treat them as such? Can a five-year-old vote or get married simply because they believe they are older?

That is also silly. Minors have restricted rights and are subject to guardianship until they reach the legal age of majority. After that they can have as many 18th birthdays as they want.

In New York City, can a transfat now enter any food it chooses?

Ha. i see what you did there. thats super clever. but no. no it cannot.

 

[Lowe0]

it's not relative to my discussion, so we'll ignore that part of it

You're kidding, right? Whether it's a choice is central to the entire debate.

 

[hoosierdoc]

b. No that is silly, Transwomen don't have mammary glands to scan. the breasts a purely cosmetic.

false. 5% breast cancers are in men because they have 5% of breast tissue on the planet



That is also silly. Minors have restricted rights and are subject to guardianship until they reach the legal age of majority. After that they can have as many 18th birthdays as they want.



Ha. i see what you did there. thats super clever. but no. no it cannot.[/QUOTE]

 

[hoosierdoc]

That is also silly. Minors have restricted rights and are subject to guardianship until they reach the legal age of majority. After that they can have as many 18th birthdays as they want.

not a minor, they believe they are 18 therefore there are no longer a minor, don't use your preconceived notions about what constitutes someone being over 18.

You're kidding, right? Whether it's a choice is central to the entire debate.

not kidding, that has zero relevance to how they are treated as the gender they are living.

 

[The Meach]

false. 5% breast cancers are in men because they have 5% of breast tissue on the planet

Actually you are correct. I did some research and it is actually suggested that trans-women receive mammograms. And after some legal battles most insurers cover the procedure.

 

[The Meach]

not a minor, they believe they are 18 therefore there are no longer a minor, don't use your preconceived notions about what constitutes someone being over 18.

The age of majority is not governed from within ones own self it is a system of subjection set forward by the state and agreed upon by the majority of the populous.

 

[jd4320t]

I like what I'm reading. I think women should be able to walk around topless and identify themselves as men. Of course they can change identity when they like because we're obviously headed to that point.

 

[RobbyMaQ]

false. 5% breast cancers are in men because they have 5% of breast tissue on the planet

My wife's grandfather died from breast cancer. it's real

 

[The Meach]

I like what I'm reading. I think women should be able to walk around topless and identify themselves as men. Of course they can change identity when they like because we're obviously headed to that point.

Topless Laws - GoTopless

 

[Tombs]

Trump should start self identifying as a hispanic to win progressives and the hispanic vote.

Imagine the possibilities!

 

[IndyDave1776]

Trump should start self identifying as a hispanic to win progressives and the hispanic vote.

Imagine the possibilities!

Yes, and I am going to start identifying as an Iowa-class battleship and start demanding DoD funding!

 

[cobber]

If A man chooses to live as a woman, now he is allowed in the women's bathroom because he has chosen to be a woman.

Is he then forced to sign up for the selective service?

Is he hit with indecent exposure if he exposes his chest? Should I do a mammogram on him every year?

If we are to believe children and their gender identity and treat them as they believe, what else does this extend to? If they believe they are 18, do we treat them as such? Can a five-year-old vote or get married simply because they believe they are older?

In New York City, can a transfat now enter any food it chooses?

You're very binary in your thinking.

 

[AA&E]

If A man chooses to live as a woman, now he is allowed in the women's bathroom because he has chosen to be a woman.

Is he then forced to sign up for the selective service?

Is he hit with indecent exposure if he exposes his chest? Should I do a mammogram on him every year?

If we are to believe children and their gender identity and treat them as they believe, what else does this extend to? If they believe they are 18, do we treat them as such? Can a five-year-old vote or get married simply because they believe they are older?

In New York City, can a transfat now enter any food it chooses?

My 2 two year found out she doesn't get to go to school like her siblings until she is 5 years old. So, she has been telling EVERYONE she is five years old. Blurts it out in the middle of conversation out of the blue. States it as fact to people she doesn't know just passing by in the grocery store. Based on your post, I'm starting to wonder if her tactic isn't brilliant!

 

[ghuns]

Whether it's a choice is central to the entire debate.

Uh, that's not a debate we're allowed to have in 2016 Murrica.

It's been decided, we are special little flowers, each born with a preprogrammed set of compulsions. There shall be no judging. There is no "normal".