Inigo Montoya For the Win!!!!!
Mister
My husband worked with a guy named Mister Smith...true story. That was his real name.
Mr. Mister Smith
Navin R. Johnson
"Sounds like a real loser!"Navin R. Johnson
"Sounds like a real loser!"
Reggie..after Reggie White #92 packers!
That's awesome. I also like GFGT's suggestion of Judge. I thought Doctor might be good too, but my surname is actually a derivation of the Latin word for doctor, so my wife thinks it would be redundant.
Someone mentioned the name Cooper. I like Cooper.