Costners in Bedford has some variety. While it is not a huge store it is not small either. While Dave isn't bad to deal with he can cuss enough to make a truck driver blush. Paul (one of the salesmen) has a good knowledge and is easy to talk to. No matter who you deal with there I have never seen them have the "you're new here so you have to prove yourself before we'll sell you anything or be pleasant" attitude that I have seen in many local gun-shops.
Dave's Guns in Holland.
Meeks Guns in Ft Branch. Check them out. The old Randys Sporting Goods has been given a face lift. More and more guns coming in daily. Jeff and Christina are great people also. They buy, sell, and trade.
Glen
Technically, Evansville has Strictly Shooting, Rajo's, Red Ghost (close-but not in the city), and Gander Mountain.
Note:
As others have pointed out to me, constantly, Rajo's & Strictly Shooting are higher than most, and might as well be considered retail on everything. Hey, don't blame me, it's the reputation they've made for themselves.
Cabin Fever between salem and scottsburg south of st rd 56 is a really nice shop
Has anybody been to the new one in Mitchell yet? It's just east on Hwy 60. Keep thinking I'll stop in, but haven't done it yet. It's pretty small and I think they just opened in the last month or so.
As Bonehead said, Cosners' has a decent selection of new and used guns.