Glock 21 sf or XD 45?

[hubbard]

Most of my guns are Glocks. I like them all. I need a .45 and have narrowed it down to Glock 21 sf or Springfield Armory XD (non M) .45.
I have looked at everything so please limit your input to these two. Any input would be appreciated. Thanks.

 

[Joe Williams]

The Glock 21 is a massive gun, and the grip is poorly shaped, IMHO.

The XD45 is much more comfortable, and better sized.

Both are fine guns, and you already know and like Glocks, so that may (should?) hold some sway.

Pick 'em up, see which you like.

 

[44 MAGNUM SHOOTER]

Most of my guns are Glocks. I like them all. I need a .45 and have narrowed it down to Glock 21 sf or Springfield Armory XD (non M) .45.
I have looked at everything so please limit your input to these two. Any input would be appreciated. Thanks.

Try the XD45 Compact. Easy to conceal with the 10 round magazine and also you get a 13 rounder as a back up. Has a slimmer grip too with an extension for larger hands.

 

[gworkman]

I would go glock and if it don't fit right u can get grips. I'm a glock guy

 

[John Galt]

I know, I know, but I just have to go outside the boundry here, since you said you love Glock and want a .45. Have you considered the Glock 37 or 38 GAP? The frame fits the hand perfect, they're accurate as all get out and you still have .45 performance in a comfortable Glock. I love mine and for the money, they're worth considering. Sorry, but I'm just trying to help and had to throw it out there!

 

[JohnP82]

Both are great guns, cant go wrong with either. I vote Glock though

You say most of your guns are Glocks, then I would stick with the Glock. Same feel, same trigger, should feel normal to you.

 

[matthewdanger]

The 21SF would get my vote of the two. If you want a polymer frames .45 that is more suitable for carry because of it's size you may want to add the 30SF and the M&P to your list.

 

[cosermann]

I really like the G30SF. The G21SF is fine too and would be my choice between the Glock 21 and full-size XD 45s, since I prefer to NOT have a grip safety as the XD series does. The Glock grip works just fine for me. Size is relative.

I'm assuming the "everything" you've looked at includes the S&W M&P45, so I will NOT mention it as a potential candidate. Oops, I guess I just did.

 

[hubbard]

Thanks, guys. I have ruled out all 1911 styles, M&P and others.

The standard G21 feels just a little to big for my hand. The 21SF does in fact feel better than the standard G21. The SA XD (not M) feels better to me than the XDm regardless of the back strap on the XDm. It must be a .45 ACP.
It is just really close. Time to shoot 'em both. Looking for your input on these two.

 

[EvilElmo]

One thing to consider is the ammo you'll use for plinking/training. IIRC because of the polygonal rifling in the Glock the warranty officially negates using cast bullets. The XDs use traditional rifling and have no cast bullet disclaimer in the warranty.

This is the major reason I steer clear of Glocks, since I shoot cast bullets almost exclusively. I know the odds of having an issue are very low but I don't see a reason to risk it when Springfield offers basically the same lineup in the XDs without the restriction.

 

[cosermann]

Conventional and polygonal rifling are different with their own strengths and weaknesses.

After market barrels are available for the Glock if you want to shoot cast bullets (i.e. Lonewolf, etc.).

Polygonal rifling - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

 

[bmmonts76]

I have the Glock 21SF and it's one of my favorite guns to shoot. I also purchased a crossbreed holster and belt and surprisingly enough it carries pretty nice in the winter time. It's not so easy to conceal with shorts and a t-shirt though.

 

[kingnereli]

I suggest the XD45. I have the five inch version and couldn't be happier with it. You're obviously not going to see a reliability or accuracy difference in the guns. The advantage of the XD is the trigger is better and the grip is much slimmer. I appreciate having an actual safety as well. However, there is something to be said for sticking to a platform you are used to. If most of your guns are glocks it may be worth it to you to go with the 21sf. Do your best to shoot both of them before you decide.

 

[GlockRock]

Glock 21

 

[L-W-R-C]

glock 21

 

[XtremeVel]

Most of my guns are Glocks. I like them all. I need a .45 and have narrowed it down to Glock 21 sf or Springfield Armory XD (non M) .45.
I have looked at everything so please limit your input to these two. Any input would be appreciated. Thanks.

Buy the G21 SF ! Don't do what I did. I owned all Glocks too but the G21 just didn't feel right in my hand so I bought the Xd-45 service. I liked it so well that I also added the 5 in tactical. I still have both today along with my Glocks. I beat myself up everytime I go to the range because I shoot the Xd's better then I do most of my Glocks.

FWIW, The most accurate load I shoot is a 200 gr cast SWC. It is a very accurate load out of the XD's, but they tend to be a little picky on the OAL. I have found it likes them best loaded to 1.250, but I will still get a few FTF at the range in both. The G21 on the other hand, functions flawlessly regardless if the OAL is 1.22 or 1.26.

 

[Joe Williams]

One thing to consider is the ammo you'll use for plinking/training. IIRC because of the polygonal rifling in the Glock the warranty officially negates using cast bullets. The XDs use traditional rifling and have no cast bullet disclaimer in the warranty.

This is the major reason I steer clear of Glocks, since I shoot cast bullets almost exclusively. I know the odds of having an issue are very low but I don't see a reason to risk it when Springfield offers basically the same lineup in the XDs without the restriction.

If you like the Glocks, there are several good aftermarket sources available with conventional rifling. They aren't expensive.

 

[LotsofGlocks]

If most of your guns are Glocks you answered your own question.

 

[U.S. Patriot]

I know you said Xd or Glock. However I would also look into the FNP 45. They are hammer fired, decocker plus safety. You get three mags, and two interchangeable back straps. They are a great pistol. Both light and accurate. I'm not a fan of Glocks, so I cant help you there. I do own an Xd, and they are great guns. Still a bit heavy compared to others.

 

[pbgear]

my vote would be glock