I would prefer something with a strap. Something like that "sky high" holster would be perfect, im not sure how well that would work with a j-frame revolver though. I would like some type of strap or something similar as compared to just a tight holster that fits well. The holster I have now is a very tight holster and fits my gun very well. I have seen revolver holsters with "hammer straps" on them in the past. Any opinions on those?