You can find a damn fine carbine with what you'd spend on the Fulton Armory version. The AO carbine, if I remember right, is around what I've seen M1's going for at the 1500 (in the $600-800 range.)
I agree with you though...I'd get the AO carbine if the price were very very right, but by default I'll always go for the surplus GI carbines.
It's a great day when you go to the CMP at Camp Perry. I picked out my very own '' Correct '' H&R M1 Garand.
Take a day, make the drive, bring a buddy.............