XDm vs. XD9sc

[drobi]

I have tried out several 9mm models over the past few weeks and really like the feel of Springfields.

I have been educating myself on these two guns, but I haven't found a main issue that would lead me to favor one over the other.

Does anyone here have experience with these two and willing to point out some pros and cons?

Thanks

 

[Moorephine]

I have an XDm .40, I'll let you know that it is a great firearm, never had a single issue with it. Much more comfortable gun than my Glock 23

 

[Bob2]

No experience with the XDm other than holding it side by side with XD9sc when trying to decide which one to buy on Black Friday. I had been wanting the sc for some time, and Midwest had them on sale for $429, and the M for $519. I liked the feel of the sc alot better than the m, and as that is what I thought I already wanted, bought it. Shot the sc and really like it, much better pattern that I get with my XDs 45

edit: The XDm I held was the compact model

 

[Hopper]

Whoa, that's a GREAT price on both from Midwest! I was eyeing both the XD SC and XDm as well, and ended up going with the XDm 40 in compact form. I suspected that being just a bit larger than the XD SC would make the XDm a better experience in 40. Match grade barrel, changeable back straps (may or may not be a selling point), and so far, it's been great, totally reliable and very accurate. The only thing I kind of wish I'd done is spent extra $$ for the bi-tone... I'm not completely happy with how the melonite black finish has worn after two range visits, and though it's never been carried, it already kind of looks like it has.

 

[drobi]

I am definitely leaning towards the sc, although I am not sure if one has a definitive advantage over the other in 9mm...besides the slightly smaller size of the sc.

 

[Bigtanker]

The XDm has a higher capacity. If a few rounds make a difference to you. Also keep in mind magazine availability. The XD mags seem plentiful but the XDm mags can be a chore to find at a decent price. I think you will be happy with either. If you can't decide, buy the XD and use the money you saved from not getting fhe XDm and buy a good holster, a few more mags and some more ammo.

BTW: I have the XDm 5.25 in 9mm and love it.