My son recently started shooting sporting clays and is reloading. It has been recommended that he not reload federal.
Appreciate your input.
The Federal plastic shells are fine. A seperate base wad is someting many reloaders shy away from, especially in a pump or semi auto because you cannot see if a base wad slips out of a hull and lodges in the barrel. The cheap Federal hulls from the value packs like at wal mart use the same reload data as Federal "Top Gun" hulls. The trick to Federal hulls is to use the right wad. Depending on your application the right wad will start with "S O" and then a number. If you are reloading on a MEC press, the primer seating stem also makes sure the base wad is fully seated. Since few people reload them, most people shooting value pack Federals are glad to give them to you for free. I would reload them once and throw them away. I shoot an O/U so I shoot them 4 or 5 times, but I can easily look down the barrel everytime I remove the old hulls so I could easily see a loose base wad. The new AA hulls have the same problems so they are falling out of favor with people who shoot a lot.
It is pretty hard to beat Hodgdon's "CLAYS" powder for most 12 gauge applications.