opinions on Springfield 1911's

[ph2o]

I've been kicking around the idea of buying a new full size 1911. I would really like an Ed Brown Kobra but the price has me scared off. I saw a Springfield PX9154 that really caught my eye. I've seen varying opinions on Springfields so what is yours?

 

[Tactical Dave]

Love my XD and love the warrenty. I want their PX9154 also at some point.

 

[garagegunmaker]

Me too. There XDs rule. I really want there 1911.

 

[Hondo]

I have a Loaded...great gun and good shooter...just had some work done to it...had the MIM parts removed and trigger job...it is as accurate as I can shoot it.

Removing the MIM parts was an optional move on my part and for regular use may not be necessary but since I had it in the shop decided to go for it.

I would buy another Springfield tomorrow....

I have a Les Baer but shoot the SA more just because I am less concerned about abusing the SA.because it was less $$$

 

[ph2o]

Hondo - The one I looked @ tonight had a pretty good stock trigger. I hope that is normal for these guns.

 

[DeadeyeChrista'sdad]

Have a compact 1911. Not a Caddillac, but definitely a good ol' Ford or Chevy.

 

[Hondo]

Hondo - The one I looked @ tonight had a pretty good stock trigger. I hope that is normal for these guns.

My trigger was good but I wanted it "crisper" with as little over travel as possible...I had the Baer done too. It was #4 out of the box I had it tuned and taken to #3.5

Bottom line the stock trigger is good....I have 5 1911's and I have them all set as close to being the same as possible at #3.5...just my personal preference

 

[42769vette]

ino springfield 1911s are the best bang for your buck in the 1911 field

 

[Grux]

I have my eye on a Springfield 1911 as well

 

[duboismd]

I have a lightweight commander and love it. My XD is one of my favorites. Their lifetime warranty is exactly that too. Even includes free shipping both ways. They take care of their customers. I would not hesitate to buy one of their products. If it "fits" you I'd go for it.

 

[cornfused]

Springfield got my pick, I'm still new to mine but I love it already!

 

[Tactical Dave]

I have a lightweight commander and love it. My XD is one of my favorites. Their lifetime warranty is exactly that too. Even includes free shipping both ways. They take care of their customers. I would not hesitate to buy one of their products. If it "fits" you I'd go for it.

My XD has a finish issue and they told me I could send it in now or WAAAY down the road......... SWEET.

 

[chizzle]

I owned a Stainless Springfield Loaded, but wish I would have purchased an STI Trojan instead. Springfield uses a different radius on their beavertails too; so you're limited on choices if you ever want to replace it (probably not a big deal). All in all, it's a Springfield is a solid choice, but I think you can get a slightly better quality gun (tighter slide to frame fit) if you choose went with an STI Trojan for ~$920.

 

[parson]

I had a Compact Loaded model and wish that I had kept it. Traded it in a moment of less than sound judgment.

 

[WIZZO499]

I'm up to 4 Springfields and I'm trying to get another one bought.

They're good stuff, just beware of the MIM extractor. They can lose tension and start giving you problems. When you re-tension them, they don't hold it as long as barstock.

 

[88E30M50]

I have a full size Springfield 1911 and do like it, but don't think it's the best value for the dollar. I have 3 1911s at the moment, an RIA Compact, Springfield full size Mil-Spec-ish and Kimber Ultra Carry. The Springfield is the only one that has ever given me trouble, but since doing a spring kit, it's been fine. It's accurate and reliable and feels good in the hand. I put a Wilson Combat trigger on it and I'm very happy with the trigger now.

The best 1911 value for me was the RIA Compact. I'm more accurate with that at 7 yards than I am with the full size Springfield, but the Springer is better at 15 yards and longer. I don't think you can go too far wrong with a Springfield 1911.

 

[Manan]

Springfield's are generally good guns. Lots of parts made in Brazil. Lower priced, good value.

My recommendation would be to go shoot one and decide if it is right for you.

Good Luck.

 

[trad78]

Got a S.A. 1911 GI. Love it! Can't go wrong. BUT, if you have any doubts, shoot one before you buy, we're not all made out of money.

 

[MilitaryArms]

Probably the best 1911's on the market right now that aren't coming out of a semi-custom/custom shop. If you do want to get custom work done, they are among the best platforms for custom work. Their steel and quality are outstanding. SA's and Colt's are generally the platforms of choice for most high-end custom builds.

If you have the money, look into the TRP from Springfield. At this point in the SA product line their pistols are really a cut above the competition. It's about as good as you'll get with hand fitted slide to frame, extractor, ejector, barrel and bushing. For the money, it's unbeatable.

 

[Claddagh]

Presently, I'm down to two, both stainless "Loaded" models: A Champion and a full-sized 1911A1.

IMO, both have given me excellent value and exceptional service. I took the Champion for the 5-day Defensive Pistol I course at the Chapman Academy several years back. Went through 2300 rds of 230 gr. ball ammo in five days with no issues or malfs other than those set up for training drills. It always ran and hit where I pointed it. Hard to fault that kind of performance from a mid-priced 1911, to my mind.

I have other, more expensive 1911's but that Champion is still my first choice for my everyday CCW.