If you buy online, you don't pay sales tax, but you do pay an FFL trasfer fee of $25 on the low end. Also, they'll be paying shipping. This means that the difference is nil if the gun costs up to $500.
Also, buying second-hand online is inferior. How can you inspect the gun? FTF is much better.
Also, it is not difficult to get into the game of selling online through GunBroker, or through your own web site, or both, taking into account new tools for making web sites. If you have trouble figuring it out, there's always kids looking for cash.
Originally Posted by Michiana
Indiana dealers work at the 7% disavantage over internet sellers so I believe people who buy from us do so out of loyalty for local businesses.
Most of the FFL's I know charge $20, not $25. Remember the dealer also has to pay shipping from their distributor which is added on to the selling price and depending on who they buy from it can be as much as $22 for a gun. I always tell people to check Gunbroker and Buds first before I quote them a price as it is often very hard to compete with Buds. I sometimes see Buds charging only a few dollars more than I have to pay "dealer cost" for a specific gun and many times shipping is included. On a $500 "my dealer cost" gun, lets figure I pay another $10 for shipping and mark the gun up 10% so I am at $560 plus 39.20 IN sales tax brings my selling price to $599.20. Buds might sell it for $550-$560 inc. shipping and with a $20 transfer fee they are still less then me. I often see guns listed on Buds for almost the same price I have to pay my distributor.
Gunbroker is all over the ball park but if you take your time you can get some decent prices. I tell my customers to do their math and sometimes I am less and sometimes I am more. People don't stop and think that there are so many different models out there it would be impossible for even big dealers to stock a small percentage of the most popular models. Check how many different versions of just Glock 17's or 22's are available. No matter what you as a dealer buy for stock your customer often wants something else. Most distributors have limited models in stock and won't tell the dealer how long it will take for them to get a specific gun in house. With Gunbroker there is a good chance someone will have that model you are looking for on sale.
I can make $20 doing a transfer without putting out a dime of my own money so it is not worth it for me to make less than $40 on a gun. That extra $20 from the gun sale doubles the time and also more paperwork for me. To compete with the Internet I sometimes have to sell a gun for $25 over cost which really makes no sense. I sell guns because I get tired of just doing transfers and also I need to service my customers. I was in the mold building business for many years and can honestly say I have on occasion spent more time selling a $500 gun, start to finish then selling and building a $10,000 mold and making $800 profit. Remember the gun shop and even the home based FFL has expenses to cover out of that small profit margin, it does not all go in our pocket.
There is a cost for listing on Gunbroker and depending on how long it takes to sell the item that cost can go up to $10 or more. If you are making $50 profit on a $500 gun that takes 20% off the top. Shipping is often a break even proposition so you have extra time involved there. I do this because it is a hobby for me and I make my spend money but the guy with the store front is making a living from his business and has to compete with the internet which is not easy.