Contact Brian at Mills Tactical if you're looking to stay in Indy. You could also reach out to Andrew @ Henry Holsters - he's south of Indy but makes a good rig if you are willing to have it shipped or set up something with him to pick it up.
I bought a Reaper holster for my 23 at the 1500 last January. I think they are on southside too. I like it alot and now I have been making my own. What kind of holster you looking for? IWB or OWB?
I realize local business is better but I'll tell you something...
Zero concealment is a good deal. $30 surprise can't be beat. They also sell on eBay. The 20 iWb ain't bade either.