Beretta M9A1 vs. HK p2000 .40sw

[usmcleatherneck]

So today I was asked if I was willing to trade my Beretta M9A1 for a HK P2000 in .40...Im sure the Hk is a fine gun but a paid close to MSRP to get the Beretta and Im not wanting to loose my rear end on the trade. Both gun only have appx. 150 rounds through them. What do you guys think?

 

[jd4320t]

Do you want the HK P2000 in 40? If you do you won't be losing anything in the trade.

 

[JimmyJames]

I would be hard pressed to let go of the Beretta.

 

[usmcleatherneck]

I could use a good CCW..and I dont mind it being a .40

 

[usmcleatherneck]

I would be hard pressed to let go of the Beretta.

I know what you mean...Its just the dag gone beretta is so large its hard to doing anything with it but use it at the range.

 

[indykid]

The Beretta is a large pistol, but it can be more than a range-gun. I keep mine firmly attached to my bed for home defense. Something about an 18 + 1 ready for what I hope never happens. (Mec-gar makes an 18 round flush fit).

Also, I have a thing about H&K and the way they care about we the people.

 

[garagegunmaker]

I could use a good CCW..and I dont mind it being a .40

I am 5' 10" 130lbs...not a big guy, and I CC my Taurus 92af (I know it's not berretta but it's the same size ) very successfully.

 

[JWAS]

I would keep the HK. The beretta trigger is nicer, but not nice enough for me to trade a perfect sized HK p2000 for the huge beretta. Plus the extra weight doesn't help since the HK manages recoil very well. Plus you would be switching to a 9mm (I prefer 9mm, but that is just me) from a 40, so again, I would keep the p2000 if you enjoy the 40cal.

I need to read better next time... lol, in any case, HK all the way.

 

[Kagnew]

You've got a Lamborghini. Do you really want to trade it for a Yugo?

 

[9mmfan]

If you haven't already, test fire it and see how you like it. I had a HK USP compact 40 that I traded for a guy looking to get rid of his G20 (). Now, the Glock didn't cost anything close to the HK (cost me 700 bills), but man, I had been looking a 10 mm for a long time, and better yet, it's a Glock

I trade the HK, Serpa and about 50 rounds. I got the Glock and about $150.
Very fair and we both got what we were looking for.

 

[garagegunmaker]

I would keep the HK. The beretta trigger is nicer, but not nice enough for me to trade a perfect sized HK p2000 for the huge beretta. Plus the extra weight doesn't help since the HK manages recoil very well. Plus you would be switching to a 9mm (I prefer 9mm, but that is just me) from a 40, so again, I would keep the p2000 if you enjoy the 40cal.

so much fail

 

[indykid]

so much fail

I saw that but for once in my life decided to refrain from pointing out the obvious.

 

[garagegunmaker]

I normally keep quiet and try not to point out others mistakes...but i couldnt help it this time

 

[usmcleatherneck]

I would keep the HK. The beretta trigger is nicer, but not nice enough for me to trade a perfect sized HK p2000 for the huge beretta. Plus the extra weight doesn't help since the HK manages recoil very well. Plus you would be switching to a 9mm (I prefer 9mm, but that is just me) from a 40, so again, I would keep the p2000 if you enjoy the 40cal.

I need to read better next time... lol, in any case, HK all the way.

DONT WORRY BOUT IT, I GOT YOUR POINT.