I know sometimes AR's are picky about what they will shoot out of them.
mostly ejection probelms. i checked my gas rings and made sure they weren't lined up. oiled it. and ran on with life. i have never heard that before, but i was told AR's were by an ingo guy we were talking to the other day. im using a PMAG.
i have had quiet a few jams in a AR before; however, ive gone swimming through muddy water with mine.
Maybe as a control test to rule out the ammo, you should by some Federal XM193 or similar "mil-spec" ammo to see if it functions better in your rifle.
Also, any accessories on the rifle, or is it bone stock? I've run mine with an H2 buffer without issues, but maybe there is something throwing off the timing just enough to cause the extraction issues.
There was another INGOer recently who was having some extraction issues that folks narrowed down to a mis-aligned gas block. What kind of gas block are you running?